IN ENGLISH
Montenegro: Media and Freedom of Expression, Regular Report 2012
Objavljeno prije
14 godinana
Objavio:
Monitor onlineMontenegrin independent media and its journalists have been exposed to new attacks and pressures over this year. These were manifested through physical assaults on journalists, financial pressures and legal proceedings. Not surprisingly, therefore, Montenegro is now ranked lower than in the previous year on the Reporters without borders’ report on media freedoms, where its 107th position is the lowest in the region. In Europe, only Belarus, Russia and Ukraine have lower rankings. The enhancement of media freedom has been one the key requirements for obtaining the date for commencement of EU accession negotiations.
Representatives of the independent media have a huge problem with regard to security and normal functioning of their newsrooms due to the pressures from the criminal and political circles.
The case of Olivera Lakic: Daily Vijesti journalist Olivera Lakic has been physically assaulted in the evening hours on March 7, 2012, in front of her house in downtown Podgorica. Ms Lakic wrote last year a series of articles on illegal production of cigarettes in the northern town of Mojkovac. After that, those in that murky business threatened Ms Lakic and her family in several ways, while the police tried to minimize and cover up the case instead of investigating it thoroughly and protecting the journalist.
A few days after the attack, the police arrested one person, who, according to Ms Lakic’s best knowledge, did not have any motive to assault her. She insisted that those who commissioned this act be found. She also announced her withdrawal from journalism, until the state authorities resolve the case.
Earlier this month (December 2012), Montenegrin prosecution authorities examined Milenko Rabrenovic, a police officer employed at the Ministry of Internal Affairs, on suspicion that he threatened Olivera Lakic and her daughter after a series of articles about the illegal cigarette trafficking in Montenegro. Mr Rabrenovic was a driver of the former Head of Montenegrin Police Authority Veselin Veljovic when these texts were published.
The case of Veselin Drljevic: In February of 2012, the editor of daily Dan Veselin Drljevic and the photographer of this paper were assaulted by a group of hooligans who inflicted several injuries on Drljevic’s face and body. Perpetrators of this attack were found and legal proceedings against them have begun.
The case of arson of Vijesti vehicles: Police did not find out who are the arsonists who torched vehicles of Vijesti. Fire was set on four vehicles of Vijesti in three night operations. Although the representatives of Police and Government have stated that they are diligently working on resolving these cases, no progress has been made after several months of investigation.
Montenegrin police and judiciary did not manage to solve numerous previous cases of physical endangering of journalists and editors in Montenegro, starting with the 2004 murder of publisher and editor Dusko Jovanovic, the 2008 murder of Srdjan Vojicic, who was a guard of Montenegrin poet Jevrem Brkovic. The same applies to subsequent attacks on Tufik Softic, Zeljko Ivanovic, Mladen Stojovic and others. One of the main requests of massive street protests in 2012 and the petition of media professionals sent to EU officials Baroso and Fule was for these cases to be solved.
The persecution of Mihailo Jovovic, Vijesti’s Editor in Chief: Three years upon the physical attack by the Podgorica mayor Miomir Mugosa and his son Miljan Mugosa on Mihailo Jovovic, Editor in Chief of Vijesti, and Boris Pejovic, its photographer, the Court has sentenced only conditionally Mayor’s son Miljan, although the court practice for all types of severe injuries similar to the one inflicted by Miljan Mugosa is to impose prison sentences. However, even after such an epilogue, the Prosecution has appealed to the Superior Court, whom it is now asking to reverse its decision and to prosecute instead the Editor in Chief for alleged attack on the Mayor’s son.
In August 2009, Jovovic and Pejovic were assaulted by Mayor Mugosa and his son while covering a story on Mayor’s repeated illegal parking and the functioning of the city’s communal police. The journalists were threatened with a gun by the Mayor’s son and Mr. Jovovic was admitted to hospital with a ruptured eardrum. Colluding with the Mayor, police failed to take any evidence from the scene, including the gun, while prosecutors falsely indicted Mr. Jovovic for attacking the Mayor’s driver and causing him serious brain injury, contrary to two expert medical opinions.
Treatment of the independent media representatives as criminals and enemies: The representatives of the independent media have been accused for being disloyal to the Montenegrin state and depicted as non-patriotic, even for belonging to the organized crime.
In many public appearances during the last year, the new prime minister and leader of the ruling political party DPS Milo Djukanovic continued the campaign against the independent media. He called the representatives of independent media rodents that need to be deratized. On more than one occasion Djukanovic has repeated that media and civil activists represent a major barrier on the Montenegrin road towards Europe, that they chase away foreign investors by writing about corruption and organized crime, and that they want to bring down the current administration by all means possible.
During the recent campaign for parliamentary elections held on 14 October, Djukanovic and his associates engaged more with the independent media than with the opposition. In his speeches, Djukanovic falsely accused the independent media for coordinating the opposition parties and announced the arrest of Miodrag Perovic, co-founder of daily Vijesti and weekly Monitor. During the campaign, Vijesti’s correspondent Goran Malidžan was physically assaulted at a DPS party rally in that city.
Media completely or partially funded by the government publish serials about the representatives of independent media, using the hate language and numerous lies. So, the female journalists and civil activists are called prostitutes, while owners and male journalists are presented as fools, animals and national traitors. In the media controlled by DPS, the attacks on independent media are openly ridiculed. The state owned daily Pobjeda is leading this propaganda.
On the other hand, only in the independent media one can find serious investigative pieces on corruption, non-transparent privatizations, links of the political elite with criminals, etc. The aim is clear – to silence and discipline the independent media, their founders, editors and journalists by publicly lynching them.
Financial pressures through advertising: The biggest portion of the total advertising budget from the state institutions – the national and local governments, agencies, ministries, state owned companies – goes mostly to the media controlled by the state and ruling political structures. A recent research conducted by the Center for Civic Education, has concluded that the state-controlled daily Pobjeda, albeit with the smallest circulation, benefits from the greatest number of advertisings by the state institutions and enterprises.
Pobjeda sells its advertising space to the state companies and institutions for much higher prices than Vijesti and Dan do. Also, Pobjeda offers very low advertising prices to private companies, thus threatening the independent media to loose its main source of revenue.
The launch of a free daily newspaper and dumping prices by competitors: On the small Montenegrin market, two daily newspapers have been launched over the past year. One of them, ‘Dnevne novine’, was established and distributed without charge for almost a year and, since very recently, is selling at a nominal price of 20 cents, while the other, named ‘Blic’, is selling at a token price of 30 cents. On a market of 650 000 inhabitants, such low dumping prices cannot be economically sustainable. The largest-selling and most influential dailies in Montenegro, ‘Vijesti’ and ‘Dan’, are sold for 70 cents. This fuels strong suspicion that the establishing of media with dumping prices is politically motivated and that the anonymous financiers are willing to invest huge fortunes in order to undermine the independent press. Needless to say, the state authorities entrusted to implement the Law on Protection of Competition are not reacting.
The ownership structure: Most of Montenegrin media are controlled by the top of DPS and are being financed in a nontransparent way. It is unclear who really stands behind them, as a significant majority is bankrupt; some have multimillion losses but still keep functioning. Government covers losses of Pobjeda and public Radio & Television of Montenegro out of its own budget. Behind the others, publicly or secretly, stand tycoons and their companies who support the propaganda in favor of the government. At the same time, the top state and DPS party officials aggressively and falsely depict the owners of daily Vijesti and weekly Monitor, the media that are struggling to survive under such oppressive circumstances, as filthy rich media monopolists and mafia.
Indicative is the case of the daily Pobjeda which remains in a majority ownership of the state, even though the Media Law of 2002 called for the privatization of this house by 2004, at the latest. Since then, two tenders have been ‘unsuccessful’, so the Government continued to finance the newspaper despite the legal provisions forbidding this.
Now, after the third announcement of the tender, the government could cede Pobjeda well below the anticipated conditions of sale. According to recently released information, it could happen that the state assumes the huge debts of Pobjeda, which amount to about 20 million. The only bidder is the Bosnian company Avaz. Owner of Avaz is controversial Fahrudin Radoncic, a longtime friend of Milo Djukanovic. Messrs Radoncic and Djukanovic were Montenegrin Communist Party officials before the multiparty system was introduced.
Court cases: Journalist of the weekly Monitor Veseljko Koprivica won the case against Montenegro in the European Court for Human Rights in Strasbourg. Explanation of judges in Strasbourg was that the penalty and damage charges for alleged libel, which were assigned to Koprivica in Montenegrin court, were not in accordance with the practice of HRC in Strasbourg. This court ruling is a great encouragement, since in the last few years dailies Vijesti and Dan and weekly Monitor paid over 300 000 euros for alleged libel and pain and suffering of the plaintiffs, former prime minister Djukanovic and his close representatives of business elite included. In a majority of these cases penalties imposed in the Montenegrin courts have not been in accordance with the practice of HRC and have jeopardized the economic survival of these media, and thus the freedom of speech and expression.
The verdict in Koprivica vs. Montenegro could positively influence the courts in Montenegro, which currently deal with many court proceedings for libel against dailies Dan and Vijesti and weekly Monitor.
It is encouraging that the Constitutional Court of Montenegro at the beginning of this year overturned the verdict of the Supreme Court against the weekly Monitor and its journalist Andrej Nikolaidis. The Constitutional Court in its interpretation of judgment called on the practice of the Court in Strasbourg.
Lawsuit by Ana Kolarevic: On the same day that it was announced that the Prime Minister will be Milo Djukanovic, his sister and lawyer Ana Kolarevic filed a lawsuit against dailies Vijesti and Dan, and the weekly Monitor, seeking compensation of 100,000 euros from each of them. The pretext is the alleged mental pain that she has suffered as a result of their reporting on the Telecom affair. Earlier this year, the US court authorities in New York opened a high-level corruption case related to the Telecom privatisation in 2005. In New York Court documents, Prime Minister Djukanovic’s sister is brought in connection with this affair and its dubious contracts, which were highlighted by the media that she is now suing. Ms Kolarevic has decided to file a lawsuit only ten months after the first articles appeared, when it was clear that her brother would return to the post of Prime Minister.
Public Radio and Television: Advisory Committee of the Public Broadcasting Service (RTCG), after the overturn of the former managing director, appointed the new one – Rade Vojvodic. Mr Vojvodic was a long term director of the private television ‘IN’, which was subsequently liquidated following a bankruptcy. He is also a close friend of Milo Djukanovic. In an ambitious program, Mr Vojvodic has announced reforms and drastic decrease of number of employees. While layoffs were initiated, Mr Vojvodic brought to RTCG most of his personnel from TV IN. According to the Independent labor union of RTCG, their hiring was in collision with the Employment law.
Although the arrival of the new management improved the viewership rating of public broadcasting services, the quality of the programme is still questionable. The editorial board now insists on entertainment and sports, for airing the Champions League, for example. and which absorb significant state budgetary funds. At the same time, educational, scientific and informative programme, which are the foundation of every public service broadcast, still have inadequate professional standards. In the news programs, the primacy is still given to the ruling parties and leading government officials, while the information on actions and views of the opposition and civil society representatives significantly lags behind.
RTCG is accused by some members of its Advisory Board for non-transparent allocation of funds in previous years, as well as for closing suspicious contracts worth millions with the off shore company Fiesta. For more than ten years, Fiesta has been an agent for leasing of satellite services for RTCG. Interestingly, the company “Fiesta” was in the middle of the corruption scandal associated with the privatization of Montenegrin Telekom.
Self regulatory bodies: After several months of deliberations, in which local OSCE and EU delegation representatives also took part, the Montenegrin media community decided to establish two self-regulatory bodies. In March 2012, the ‘Media self-regulatory body’ was formed, bringing together 19 electronic and print media. A significant number of these media is financed from state and local budgets, while a majority of them does not keep distance from the ruling structures. Since their inception, they have commented mostly the activities of dailies Vijesti and Dan, TV Vijesti and weekly Monitor, instead of focusing on their founders.
On the other hand, dailies Vijesti and Dan and the weekly Monitor, which had advocated the establishment of two separate bodies since the beginning of these deliberations – one which would deal with issues of self-regulation in the print media and the other in the electronic media – formed a working group for establishment of a Press council. The working group has drafted the key documents and announced the creation of the Council.
Željko Ivanović, CEO daily Vijesti
Mladen Milutinović, CEO daily Dan
Milka Tadić Mijović, CEO Monitor weekly
Podgorica, 27 December 2012
Komentari
IN ENGLISH
INSTITUTIONAL CRISIS IN POLAND: “Judgment Tuesday” and its unpredictable consequences
Objavljeno prije
3 danana
17 Novembra, 2026
The events of November 3rd—a day dubbed “Judgment Tuesday”—have plunged the country into a dangerous institutional deadlock. Specifically, eight judges of the Constitutional Tribunal, appointed by the pro-European parliamentary majority, suspended the court’s president and vice-president for one month. A judge aligned with the ruling coalition has taken over the leadership of the institution. A spokesperson for Polish President Nawrocki announced that the President is open to discussions with Prime Minister Tusk regarding the constitutional crisis. This has offered a glimmer of hope that the conflict between liberals and conservatives—which threatens to destroy Poland’s political system—might be overcome
On November 3, the spokesman of Polish president Karol Nawrocki announced that the president is open to meeting prime minister Donald Tusk to discuss the escalating constitutional crisis. It gave a fragile hope that the confrontations between liberals and conservatives that threatens to destroy Poland’s political system will be overcome. The previous events of November 3, after which that day has been named the “Judgment Tuesday” (“Sądny Wtorek”), pushed the country into a dangerous institutional dead end. The meeting of eight judges of the Constitutional Tribunal (Trybunal Konstytucyjny, TK), appointed by the current pro-European parliamentary majority, suspended for one month court’s president Bogdan Święczkowski and vice president Bartłomiej Sochański. Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, a government-aligned judge, assumed leadership of the institution.
There are two important details, concerning the meeting of eight government-backed judges. First, they were all appointed by the ruling coalition led by Donald Tusk, but only five of them were not brought to oath by the president. Karol Nawrocki is supported by Law and Justice party (PiS), which remains the largest party in the parliament, but lost the majority after 2023 parliamentary elections. It is obvious that the president vetted the judges elected by the liberal coalition, due to political reasons. Nevertheless, the oath is required by law. And chief justice of the TK Bogdan Święczkowski had a procedural basis for denying the new judges the opportunity to fulfill their duties.
Second, the TK consists of the 15 judges, who are elected by the Seim, the lower house of the parliament for nine years. However, under Polish law the presence of the presence of the two-thirds of the total number of judges is required. And there were only 8 of them at the meeting. So the decisions taken on the “Judgment Tuesday” cannot considered to be valid. But Donald Tusk is not going to acknowledge that, at least at the present moment.
The prime minister needs the admission of the new judges into the TK to carry out demands of the EU. In July, the TK refused to recognize same-sex marriages as lawful in Poland. It should be mentioned that it had a good reason for that. Article 18 of Poland’s Constitution clearly defines marriage as a union between a man and a woman. However, there can be little doubt that the liberal judges elected by the current majority would be able to find a compromise.
During the election campaign in 2023, Donald Tusk promised to end almost total abortion ban, and that brought his Civic Coalition huge number of women’s voices. In October 2020, the TK confirmed that an abortion can be allowed only if the pregnancy is the result of a criminal act (rape or incest) or if it poses a threat to a woman’s health. Tusk failed to fulfill his promise. The ruling parliamentary coalition includes, besides a liberal party of Tusk and New Left, the parties that depend on support of people, who adhere to religious views. Because of that, amendments passed by the the Sejm on October 20, just ease penalties for helping women terminate pregnancy and allow abortion in cases of severe fetal abnormalities. There is a great chance that the president will put a veto on the newly passed amendments, and his decision will be supported by the conservative TK, which remains under the influence of PiS.
On October 30, the dangerous political crisis began unfolding. The government-backed judges forcibly took control of the court. President of the TK Bogdan Święczkowski and his deputy Bartłomiej Sochański were informed that they will not be admitted to the meetings. Police was deployed at the TK building and around it. Święczkowski’s supporters attempted to break police lines, in order to clear the way for him into the building.
During the night, president Karol Nawrocki returned to Warsaw, having cut short a trip to Senegal. He arrived in person to meet the the protesters and physically forced his way into the TK building alongside riot police and demonstrators.
The government declared that it was compelled to use force to restore democratic rule of law to a court, which was illegally controlled by the PiS appointees. However, it seems to be impossible to defend the rule of law by breaking it, even if the conservatives used the legal requirements for their political advantage. By the way, Russian president Vladimir Putin in 2020 gained personal control over the Constitutional court, under the pretext of its ineffectiveness. Since then, the Russian judicial system has not become more effective, though it now completely depends on the Kremlin.
Of course Tusk cannot be suspected in establishing a regime of personal power. He is trying to make Poland more liberal. Nevertheless, the ultimate outcome of his activity may differ a lot from his intentions. In the contemporary society, democracy has to be focused on rules and procedures. Otherwise, the democratic institutions will inevitably become manipulated for the advantage of the most powerful political and business groups. Democratic procedures can appear prolonged and boring, they can be used to hinder progressive changes, but there is no alternative to them.
An influential journalist Pawel Lisicki, who is the editor-in-chief of an independent weekly political magazine “To the point” (“Do Rzeczy”) compared the capturing of the TK with actions of Serbian students, who entered the Informer TV newsroom in October 26, interrupted functioning of the channel and escorted its owner Dragan Vucicevic out of the building.
In both cases, the goal was to ease promoting progressive changes, but the most significant outcome was further polarization of society and creating obstacles for finding a compromise with the conservative part of the society.
PiS politicians branded the meeting of eight judges an “organized crime assembly” and threatened them with imprisonment. Even before “Judgment Tuesday”, president Nawrocki denounced the takeover of the TK as an unconstitutional “coup d’état”. Following “Judgment Tuesday,” the presidential administration officially announced plans to file criminal complaints against the government for the unlawful seizure of a state institution. In his turn, prime minister on Ocntober 31, declared that the TK ‘in the form imposed by PiS was not a genuine court’. Donald Tusk also stated that “in certain matters, there can be no compromise”, despite that the protest have already become fierce and riot police had been required to protect the court’s building.
Leader of PiS Jaroslaw Kaczyński has quickly become the main figure of the protest. But he is not alone. He has been joined by eaders of the Confederation party, which always tried to stay away from the conflict between Kaczyński and Tusk. It is even more important that the Confederation party also officially called Tusk’s actions as a “coup d’état” and “usurpation.”
Moreover, former prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki, who headed the last PiS government dismissed after 2023 elections, also arrived to support the protest. Joining the actions led by PiS is obviously harmful for his own political plans. Morawiecki on 24 July was removed from PiS, and soon he announced plans to form his own political party and separately run for the 2027 elections. Morawiecki was coldly met by PiS the protesters outside the TK building, but it did not stopped him from giving full support to Kaczyński’s demands.
Morawiecki November 2 announced the establishment of an investigative committee regarding actions of Donald Tusk’s associates and warned them of consequences. He promised to ensure that “all those responsible an illegal takeover of the Constitutional Tribunal”, carried out with the help of the police, are punished by law.
Morawiecki plans to launch a parliamentary investigation of the actions of the police, the State Protection Service, and government representatives, can be blocked the parliamentary majority. However, the conservatives are united now as never before, and they regard Kaczyński as their temporarily leader. Conservatives are ready to fight against Donald Tusk’s government and they can gain enough public support for a long-lasting struggle. It can be regarded as the main outcome of the “Judgment Tuesday” so far.
It is hard to say now what can be other consequences of the current crises for the Poland. It seems that the country can be deeply divided by the conflict conflict between liberals and national-conservatives. If it is not stopped, Poland will be forced to focus on overcoming its domestic division, and will have to diminish its foreign activity. And this can heavily damage plans of the the US administration to build a new European security architecture, in which Poland is supposed to play the main part.
It seems to be a mistake to expect US president Donald Trump to refuse from his international projects, which are insignificant for the American public opinion, and concentrate on domestic problems in order to restore popularity of the Republican party after its defeat at the midterm elections. First, Trump cannot be interested in increasing public support of the Republicans, if he intends to control the party nominations after the end of his term. The party lost all its supporters, who did not like Trump. According to the latest polls, 90% of the Republican voters approve Trump’s activity. It means, that in the current circumstances, Trump’s endorsement remains essential for every Republican politician. Second, the American society is highly polarized. The Republican party has turned into the party of middle-aged white people, who mostly live in the rural areas. Due to that, it has become easily managed, and it will give it some advantages at the presidential elections over Democrats because of their highly diversified base. Third, Trump is building an Empire, and he badly needs more reliable leader of the EU, then Germany and France, which try to oppose Tump’s plans. With the American support, Poland can become the political leader of Europe. Its army is becoming stronger and its economic dependence of Germany has greatly diminished. And it seems to be the only country in Europe, where both conservatives and liberals regard Russia as the main adversary. So there is no danger of independent communications between Russia and Poland. But if the due to the consequences of the “Judgment Tuesday”, Poland gets divided, it will become useless for Trump’s plans and will have to refuse from its own geopolitical ambitions.
Dmitri GALKIN
Komentari
IN ENGLISH
A GLOBAL EQUATION WITH THREE UNKNOWNS: Negotiations in Shenzhen will determine Trump’s plans for Russia and Europe
Objavljeno prije
1 sedmicana
13 Novembra, 2026
The US remains the only country that can offer Russia what it desperately needs, and in exchange, secure a cessation of hostilities. Unlike the EU, Trump has no objection to Russia retaining the territories it has seized, provided that Ukrainian forces withdraw from the part of the Donbas currently under Ukrainian control. However, he will not assist Russia in achieving this until he defines what kind of relationship he actually wants with Russia and Europe.
On November 11, The South China Morning Post, a Hong Kong’s newspaper, which is often used by Chinese government to express its position, reported that situation in Ukraine would not be discussed at the trilateral meeting of the leaders of the US, Russia and China. The meeting is scheduled to take place on the sidelines of APEC Economic summit, which will be held in Chinese Shenzhen on November 18-19.
Russian president Vladimir Putin was certainly informed about the unwillingness of the Chinese leader Xi Jinping to include the peace settlement in Ukraine into the agenda of the meeting long before it was stated publicly. Due to that, the negotiations in Abu Dhabi, that took place on November 10-11, had been doomed, before it was even started. The main obstacle to peace has been remaining the same for the last two years. The Kremlin wants the territory of whole Donbas region. It is less than Russia demanded in the beginning of the war. There is no practical possibility of conquering the Southern and Eastern Ukraine, not to mention capturing of Kyiv, which was supposed to happen according to initial Putin plans. However, Ukraine’s president still cannot comply with Russian demands without ruining his political career. Therefore, the truce can be established, either if Kyiv is compelled by Washington to make concessions, or if Putin is offered something so attractive and significant that he will suppress his desire to look like an obvious winner.
There is only one thing that Putin wants more than to demonstrate Russians that he managed to recollect “historical Russian lands” and to show Europeans that he can effectively use military force to achieve his goals. He wants to be regarded as a ruler, who has returned the status of global power to Russia. Soon after the annexation of the Crimea the idea of negotiations between Russia, the US and China, similar to a new Yalta conference, at which Stalin, Roosevelt and Churchill agreed on division of the post-war spheres of influence in February 1945. It was clear, that Biden’s administration would never agree on such negotiations. So the execution of the “New Yalta” project was postponed. But the Kremlin has never forgotten about it.
The trilateral meeting, scheduled in Shenzhen was not exactly what Putin and his associates imagined, but it would certainly help create in impression that Russia is recognized as one of the global powers. Therefore, it will provide an opportunity for Moscow to agree on serious concessions in order to end the war in Ukraine. In that case, leaving a part of Donbas outside Russia would look, as a sacrifice made in the name of consensus between the three global leaders.
If the situation in Ukraine is not discussed, Putin will lose the opportunity to make territorial compromises, not admitting his failure. In that case, he has no need to reduce his demands on territorial gains. It seems, that Abu Dhabi negotiations were regarded by the Kremlin as a prelude to the meeting of the world’s three largest nuclear powers. That’s why Moscow insists on discussion of the architecture of security of the whole Eurasia (and not just of Europe). It is supposed to find a pretext for engaging China in working out conditions of the peace settlement in Ukraine. The Kremlin even organized International collective security Forum with the participation with the participation of the representatives of member states of the Shanghai cooperation organization. The Forum was held on November 10, the same day the Abu Dhabi talks started.
However, after Beijing had refused to debate on the conditions of peace in Ukraine, the discussion of Eurasian peace architecture lost any practical meaning for the Kremlin. Head of Russian delegation in Abu Dhabi Vladimir Medinsky, an advisor to the Russian president, turned the talks on security issues into a farce. He demanded withdraw of military infrastructure and NATO formations from all the countries that joined the alliance after 1997. It is hard to imagine a person, who believes that it can be really carried out, especially in the current circumstances. Medinsky was pretending to insist on that just to stress that Russia does not seek any compromises. He also made an appeal to cede Russia all the Ukrainian territories occupied Russian troops, even outside the regions that Russia regards as a new part of its territory. He said that the land on which Russian soldier stepped on, should belong to Russia. It is a refusal even to think about peace before Ukraine’s capitulation.
Of course, it does not mean that Medinsky’s declarations should be regarded as an expression of the Kremlin’s final position that cannot be changed. It is just an attempt to suspend the discussion, until Putin decides that he can gain more from ending the war than from going on with it. He expected China to provide him with a good pretext for concessions. It is not going to happen. The EU leaders do not want Russian to look like a winner, and the EU delegation in Abu Dhabi demonstrated it once again. So the US remains the only country that can offer to Russia something it badly needs and make Russia terminate the hostilities. It should be taken into consideration that financial difficulties that Russia is facing because of the war are increasing, despite the high prices on oil. So Putin’s demands will be inevitably reduced. Nevertheless, he can refuse from capturing the territory of the whole Donbas only in exchange of something extraordinary attractive. And the US president Donald Trump is concentrated on reaching his own goals, and needs Russia significantly less than Vladimir Putin appears to think.
In contrast with the EU, Trump has nothing against granting to Russia all its territorial gains and withdrawing Ukrainian troops from the part of Donbas that still remains under Ukraine’s control. But will not help Russia to achieve that until he knows what relations between Russia and Europe he needs.
Trump’s plans were also disrupted by Xi Jinping’s intentions to bring the agenda of discussion in alignment with China’s requirements. It is extremely important for Trump to make China stop increasing its nuclear arsenal, which threatens first of all to Japan and South Korea, two main American allies in the Eastern Asia and ensure Chine’s military dominance in the region. Beijing, in its turn, is interested in strengthening national nuclear capability.
Trump and US Secretary of State Marco Rubio stated that China must be included in a new agreement that limits nuclear arsenals, and that this issue should be addressed in Shenzhen. Beijing, however, has categorically rejected any trilateral discussion on the matter. China does not want to be constrained by a treaty. Chinese nuclear arsenal remains significantly smaller than Russian and American ones. If China is not allowed to enlarge it, Beijing will not be able to offer its allies the same military protection as the US. And it can hinder Chinese global expansion, which in the current circumstances can become essential for retaining an achieved level of economic prosperity.
It has been reported that China suggested to focus the discussion on establishing restrictions on integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into nuclear arsenals. However, the outcome of such debates might be harmful for the American plans. Leading the world in AI appears in the beginning of the official list of the White House priorities. And the Trump’s administration hardly needs any restrictions, which can obstruct gaining all possible advantages from such global leadership. Besides, an agreement on the military use of AI, even if it is reached, will not help to prevent China from increasing its nuclear arsenal.
The expectations of the US, Russia and China from their trilateral meeting significantly differs. They has not been able so far even to overcome contradictions on the the format and agenda of the negotiations. Beijing insists that the meeting follow a script fully determined in advance, in order to avoid any unexpected development of discussion. The Trump administration, in its turn, is insisting on a free exchange of views, unconstrained by rigid protocol. Xi Jinping because of domestic political situation has to avoid anything unpredictable, because he needs nothing from the upcoming summit but the propaganda effect, that can have an impact on the public mind.
The recent plenum of the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), which ended on October 29, adopted the resolution, which urges the CCP to strengthen internal discipline, and fight against nepotism. It means that anti-corruption campaign started by Xi Jinping in 2012 will be continued. The data on the results of this campaign is unavailable, but it is known that almost 2,4 million of state and party bureaucrats (including police and military) were prosecuted or disciplined by 2023. And since then the campaign has been increased. There was a historically low attendance rate at the plenum, just 74%, 97 members failed to attend. It was supposed that they were absent, because they under investigation. The plenum confirmed 33 expulsions from the Central Comitte (which is a record). Due to the ongoing attempts of Xi Jinping to subdue opposition of the army to his military strategy, 16 out of the expelled officials were military commanders, and the representation of the army has sharply diminished. In such circumstances, Xi Jinping cannot appear neither too soft, no too aggressive in regard to national security issues and avoid any negotiations , which cam lead to fatal decisions. Therefore, Xi Jinping cannot even discuss any significant concessions, which can impact national security or economic development.
So Trump will have to have to increase pressure on China to make Beijing start negotiations. And to achieve that he needs to have Russia on his side. Russia should become politically dependable on the Trump administration. Due to that confrontation between the EU and Russia should be intensified, but the US should remain in good relations with both of them. So it can be expected that Trump’s attitude to the EU will be improved. The EU delegation was invited to the negotiations in Abu Dnabi, though initially they were supposed to be held in the trilateral format (between Russia, the US and Ukraine). There is no doubt, that Trump wants to end hostilities in Ukraine as soon as possible, because he is willing to start joint projects with Russia connected with oil and gas export. But as the negotiations in Abu Dhabi has shown, Washing is going to refrain from compelling Kyiv to make territorial concessions to Russia. Moscow has to be in strong need of the US support, and should be brought on the edge of the military conflict with the EU. Only in that case, it can be made to join the US demands of an agreement on restriction of nuclear arsenals. Further escalation of the conflict between the Russia and the EU can be extremely dangerous for both sides, but Trump hardly has any concerns about it. At least, until there is a chance that he might get what he needs by manipulating Putin.
Komentari
IN ENGLISH
Uncertain Fate of Wars in Ukraine and Iran: Trump Does Not Need Peaceful Solutions Before a Deal with China
Objavljeno prije
3 sedmicena
1 Novembra, 2026
At present, Trump is interest to keep the conflict in Ukraine in its current state. According to his vision, Ukraine should not be defeated, but it should find itself in a difficult situation from which it cannot extricate itself on its own. Furthermore, Trump has no need for a peace agreement with Iran at this time. In a speech before the UN General Assembly, he told Iranian leaders to understand that he is “not running for office” and that the potential outcome of the U.S. Elections cannot influence his approach to the war
On October 20, it was reported that Elon Musk ordered a slowdown of Starshield (a military-grade satellite network built by SpaceX) services in Ukraine. Musk himself had earlier denied giving any direct orders. However, it is easy to comprehend the reasons both for his decision to slowdown Starshield, and for attempts to evade responsibility for it. Like many people, who got involved in politics, but have no political talents, he understands others too literally and too easily gets confused, when his mistakes are found out. The US president Donald Trump did not want Ukraine to lose ability to conduct air-attacks in the depths of Russian territory. He just wanted to show that he was annoyed with Ukraine and justify his intentions to start economic cooperation with Russia before establishing truce. Trump does not need Russian problems to be solved before the agreement with the Kremlin is reached. In accordance with his intentions, Ukraine should not be defeated, but it should be in a difficult situation and unable to find a way out of it by itself. Musk can be advised to take an example from Pete Hegseth, the US secretary of war, who did not forbid to supply Ukraine with missiles for “Patriot” air defense systems. He is not just giving permission to do it.
At present, Trump does not need peaceful solutions both in Iran and Ukraine, because after his failure in the war with Iran, he wants to work out a new strategy first. And it, in its turn, will depend on his agreement with China. Until it is reached, he is interested to keep both conflicts in their current state. Any efforts to make him take a decision will prove to be fruitless.
On October 16, Russian president Vladimir Putin chaired a meeting with senior members of the General staff of the Russian armed forces. It should be noted that after the famous American public relations firm Ketchum terminated its contract for managing the Kremlin’s image in 2015, the organization of the events with Putin’s participation has been gradually deteriorating. The meeting purposed to persuade everyone that Russia is very close to victory, was held under the camouflage net, but inside the building. Such design was surely supposed to create impression that the leaders of the successful army are commanding its offensive operations close to the battlefield. It just looked comically. However, even if the meeting had more persuasive appearance, it would not influence Trump’s position. He is not trying to help the Kremlin to end the war on its terms. He just showed that he would be willing to do it, if he found it useful. There were forecasts that special envoys of the US president Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner would demand capitulation from Ukrainian president Volodymir Zelenskyy at the negotiations in Oslo, on October 20. Those dark predictions proved to be wrong. Witkoff and Kushner came to discuss the potential peace frameworks and confirm that the US resume sharing early-warning data on Russian missile attacks.
Trump’s approach to the resolution of the war with Iran is the same. He has nothing against it, he just does not need it now. The American president at his speech at the UN General assembly warned Iranian leaders that they were making a mistake thinking that he would need a peace treaty to improve the results of the Republican party on the Congress midterm elections. He advised them to realize that “he is not running” and the possible outcome of elections cannot influence his approach to the war. The US president might exaggerate his indifference to the election results. However, the analyses of the US political situation can prove that he is basically sincere. The upcoming elections cannot prevent him from taking a decisive part in nomination of the Republican candidate in the presidential elections. Even if the Republican party lose majority in congress both chambers, it will not be able to refuse from Trump’s leadership, because he remains much more popular than any other Republican politician. And success of the Democratic party in the Congress elections does not mean that it will be able to find a presidential candidate, who can seriously count on victory.
Nevertheless, the Iranian government tried once again to persuade Trump to come to an agreement. On October 18, Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi made an offer to open the Strait of Hormuz on the sidelines of an Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) meeting in Baghdad. Araghchi stated, that the strait could be opened within seven days. He reiterated that the conditions for this include an end to the U.S. blockade of Iranian ports and the lifting of sanctions on oil exports. Iranian proposal looks attractive now, when the Brent crude oil is trading at almost 110 USD per barrel. But there are no signs that the US president cares about oil prices so much that he would sacrifice freedom of action in exchange for their decrease.
Of course, high oil prices worsen economic situation worldwide, including the US, but American oil corporations make huge profits because of them. And even after the comparatively safe “southern route” through the Strait of Hormuz was established under US naval protection in the middle of the summer, Trump from time to time threatened to resume air-strikes on Iran preventing oil-prices from falling. The US president never carried out his promises. He also blocked the plans of Israeli prime minister Benjamim Netanjahu to launch large-scale airstrikes earlier strikes against Iran earlier in October. Trump does not neither a peace agreement with Iran, nor a resumption of the war, before he can work out a new approach to global affairs.
That’s why the US will not respond to the new strikes on commercial vessels committed by the the Iranian Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC). On October 17, IRGC declared the Strait of Hormuz closed to all passages and called the “southern route” illegal.
Such an action put more weight on Araghchi’s speech at the OIC meeting, and showed that Iran wants peace, though Iranian forces can still control one of the most important global trade routes. On October 19, the IRGC reported that three oil tankers were set ablaze due to the explosion of mines planted by the IRGC Navy. It means that Iran has no reason to capitulate, and the US will have to make concessions to achieve an agreement. However, the US administration can not carry out meaningful negotiations right now. First, it should evaluate the level of compromise. And it depends on the outcome of the negotiations with China.
It became obvious, that the US will not be able to obtain full control over the Strait of Hormuz and the Iranian oil export. So the US administration can reach only one of the primary goals of the war against Iran, a significant reduction in Iran’s uranium enrichment. Of course, it is extremely important for Israeli national security and military domination in the region. But it has also strategic significance for the Trump’s administration. After Iran cease to impose a potential threat to the key American allies in the Middle East and lose a chance to compete Israel on the same footing, the US administration will be able to reduce its military presence in the region. It costs a lot, and without control over the main sea trade routes has little value for Donald Trump, who believes that the US does not need geopolitical engagements, which do not bring advantages in international trade. But the conditions of peace of Iran has to be extremely severe, if Washington cannot persuade Beijing to
stop increasing its nuclear arsenal. In that case, the US will have to maintain its military presence in the main global regions anyway. Putting strong pressure on Iran until its capitulation will give both a goal and a justification for the military activity in the Middle East. If China agrees on the US terms, the peace between the US and Iran can be concluded on the terms that will just guarantee the absence of the nuclear weapons at Iran’s disposal in the foreseeable future.
Donald Trump has already tried to make president of China Xi Jinping start negotiations on restrictions of nuclear arsenal. He even refused to prolong New START treaty with Russia which expired on February 5, under pretext that it is necessary to include China in the new agreement. New Start treaty signed by Washington and Moscow in 2010 limited each country to no more than 1550 deployed strategic nuclear warheads. At present, China has no more than 600 warheads altogether. So Xi Jinping refused to discuss any restrictions on increasing nuclear arsenals, explaining that Chinese nuclear capabilities cannot be even compared with Russian and American. But because China continues to increase the number of warheads, the US are facing a difficult problem. Washington will have to spend money on modernizing American missiles instead of concentrating on development and production of conventional weapons.
Nuclear warheads were extremely important during the “cold war”, when two rival blocs competed for global domination. The Trump’s administration wants the US to become the sole leading power of the world (it seems to be unachievable, but it is another question). A huge nuclear arsenal is irrelevant for this purpose, but without the most advanced conventional weapons it cannot be reached. The US will gladly agree to diminish the number of deployed warheads, if it will help to avoid expenses on the development and production of new missiles. It seems that Beijing does not want to give Washington such an opportunity.
However, thanks to Vladimir Putin, Donald Trump will have an opportunity to make one more attempt to persuade Xi Jinping, offering him something in return, including peace with Iran on the terms which will make it possible to resume export of the Iranian oil to China. The Russian President managed to organize trilateral talks between Russia, China and the US on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit, scheduled for November 18–19 in Shenzhen.
It has become known that Putin and Trump discussed the possibility of the trilateral meeting during their phone call on October 9. But it was confirmed only on October 19 that the meeting will actually tale place, after Beijing decided to take part in negotiations. Trump stated that the discussions would focus primarily on nuclear weapons. Vladimir Putin wants first of all to work out the common plan of ending the war in Ukraine in hopes of making Donald Trump and Xi Jinping agree on his conditions. Trump stated that he would do “everything he can to end the war.” It means that Trump can significantly increase pressure on Ukraine, if he comes to understanding with China and finds no need to increase confrontation with Beijing. The peace in Ukraine on Russian conditions will inevitably lead to a long-lasting conflict between Russia and the EU. It will make Russia politically dependent on China. The EU, in its turn, will be compelled to concentrate on opposing Russian and on fighting internal divisions. And it will be the exact peaceful solution Donald Trump needs.
Dmitry GALKIN
Komentari

INSTITUTIONAL CRISIS IN POLAND: “Judgment Tuesday” and its unpredictable consequences
EU PUT I NEKAŽNJENI RATNI ZLOČINI: Saglasni u zaboravu
STANOVI ZA PRIVILEGOVANE IZMEĐU PARLAMENTA I USTAVNOG SUDA: Što se grbo rodi…
Izdvajamo
-
IN ENGLISH3 sedmiceBACKGROUND OF MIHAILO ZINČUK’S MISSION IN MONTENEGRO: Helped to be discovered
-
IN ENGLISH3 sedmiceUncertain Fate of Wars in Ukraine and Iran: Trump Does Not Need Peaceful Solutions Before a Deal with China
-
IN ENGLISH3 danaINSTITUTIONAL CRISIS IN POLAND: “Judgment Tuesday” and its unpredictable consequences
-
IN ENGLISH3 sedmiceDROUGHT AND TWO WARS CREATE GRAIN SHORTAGE: On the brink of global famine
-
DRUŠTVO4 sedmiceŠKOLE NA SJEVERU: Za deceniju 4000 manje osnovaca
-
DRUŠTVO4 sedmiceBUDVA IZMEĐU DVA MEĐUNARODNA KONKURSA: Za ideje utrošeno 300.000 a promenada i dalje čeka
-
DRUŠTVO4 sedmiceDRI DALA DVOSTRUKO NEGATIVNO MIŠLJENJE MINISTARSTVU ZDRAVLJA: Milioni bez potpunog revizorskog traga
-
Izdvojeno4 sedmiceNEIZVJESNA SUDBINA RATOVA U UKRAJINI I IRANU: Trampu nisu potrebna mirna rješenja prije sporazuma s Kinom
